Why your renovation quote is higher than another usually comes down to three things: the scope is not the same, the assumptions are different, or the allowances are doing the work. Ask each builder for the exclusions and the allowance schedule in writing before you compare totals.
We are not the cheapest. We do not aim to be. That sentence sits on our About page and it is worth explaining properly, because it is the question most people are thinking and almost nobody asks.

When three builders quote the same renovation and the numbers come back thousands apart, most people assume the low one found efficiencies. Occasionally that is true. Far more often, one of three other things is happening.
The scope is not the same. Two quotes for the same job are rarely for the same work. One includes the electrical upgrade the house will need, the other assumes the existing board is fine. One prices proper waterproofing to the new wet areas, the other prices the minimum. You are not comparing prices. You are comparing two different projects that happen to be described with the same words.
The assumptions are different. Every quote rests on assumptions about what is behind the walls, under the floor and in the ground. A builder who has investigated makes fewer assumptions and prices closer to reality. A builder who has not investigated makes more assumptions, prices lower, and finds out later. You pay for the difference as variations.
The allowances are doing the work. A quote can be made to look competitive by putting soft numbers against everything not yet chosen. The kitchen, the tiling, the joinery, the site works. Each one is a place the price can move after you sign.
How to compare quotes properly
Do not start with the total. Start with three questions.
What is excluded. Ask each builder for a written list of what is not in the price. The differences between those lists explain most of the gap.
What is allowed rather than priced. Ask for the allowance schedule and what percentage of the total it represents. A quote where twenty per cent of the value sits in allowances is not really a fixed price.
What happens when an assumption is wrong. Ask each builder what happens if the soil classification comes back worse than assumed, or if there is unapproved previous work behind a wall. The answer tells you who carries that risk.
What a higher quote usually buys
A properly investigated house, so fewer surprises become your problem. A fully scoped job, so the number at the end matches the number at the start. A builder who is not running so many jobs that yours becomes the one that waits. And time, in the form of a completion date somebody is prepared to put in writing.
You are not paying more for the same house. You are paying for a different level of certainty about what the house will cost and when you will get it back.
The honest version
There are builders cheaper than us who will do a good job. There are also builders cheaper than us because they have not priced the work properly, and the difference will find you in month four.
We would rather have the harder conversation at quote stage than the much harder one halfway through your build. If our number is higher than another, ask us to show you why, line by line. If we cannot justify it, you should not pay it.
For the rules that apply to domestic building contracts in Queensland, see the QBCC’s guide to contract and agreement types.
Comparing renovation quotes? Contact Swanson Constructions or call us on 0489 080 958 and we will show you why our number is what it is, line by line.
Link back to the epic post: What a Major Renovation Really Costs in the Redlands.
Why Your Renovation Quote Is Higher: Common Questions
Why is one renovation quote thousands higher than another?
Usually because the two quotes are not for the same job. The scope can differ, the assumptions about what is behind the walls and under the floor can differ, or soft allowances can be making one number look competitive. Comparing the totals tells you little until you compare what each quote includes and leaves out.
Does the cheapest quote mean the cheapest renovation?
Not reliably. There are builders cheaper than us who will do a good job. There are also builders cheaper because they have not priced the work properly, and the difference tends to find you in month four, as variations. Compare scope, exclusions and allowances, line by line, before you compare the price.
What should I ask when comparing renovation quotes?
Ask three things: what is excluded, what is allowed rather than priced, and what happens when an assumption is wrong. Ask each builder for the exclusions and the allowance schedule in writing, and ask what happens if the soil classification comes back worse than assumed or unapproved previous work turns up behind a wall.
How much of a quote can sit in allowances?
Ask for the allowance schedule and what percentage of the total it represents. A quote where twenty per cent of the value sits in allowances is not really a fixed price. Each allowance is a soft number against something not yet chosen, like the kitchen, tiling or joinery, and the price can move after you sign.
What does a higher renovation quote usually buy?
A properly investigated house, so fewer surprises become your problem, and a fully scoped job, so the number at the end matches the number at the start. It also buys a builder who is not running so many jobs that yours becomes the one that waits, and a completion date somebody is prepared to put in writing.
Related Articles
